Skip to main content

One Of Us Is Lying by Karen McManus

One of Us Is Lying follows a multiple point of view murder mystery centered around five students that attend detention. Only four get out alive. The victim, known for exposing everyone's darkest secrets through a gossip app, has plenty of enemies, but who has the biggest motive? Based loosely on The Breakfast Club, the four contrasting personalities begin to figure out what really went down in the classroom that day in order to clear their names.

Genre: Young Adult Mystery
Ideal for Fans of: Pretty Little Liars, Riverdale, Gossip Girl
Themes: Betrayal, Family, Social Stereotypes 
POV: Multiple

Upon hearing this synopsis, I freaked the hell out. A Geek, a Jock, a Criminal and a Princess, all caught up in a murder investigation? Let me tell you, this hits the jackpot. My immediate reaction after finishing it was slightly unstable and I say that with pride.  
First of all, it is imperial that I state outright - I rarely read standalones. The key reason for this, is that I fall deeply in love with the characters and story and then that love is ripped away after a few hundred pages. One of Us Is Lying fits perfectly into this scenario. Yet, I never would have detested myself more if I had not read this book.

This is a very intricate story, the twists are cleverly plotted out and the character growth is off the charts. Standalone books often lack character development, as it is difficult for a character to learn from their mistakes in a single novel, yet somehow McManus masters this perfectly. 

At first instance, we are exposed to the characters acting in line with their stereotypes, such as Addy 'The Princess' being perceived as shallow and hopelessly in love with her sports star boyfriend and Nate 'The Criminal' who is immediately viewed as the murderer due to his reputation. I need not tell you how misconceptions about someone can have an impact on their sense of identity. Reading about these four individuals, each with a different label attached to them, is very relatable to a lot of young adults and it's empowering how they all grow into themselves by the end.

A great deal of the story focuses on family and friendship and what it is like to be put into the limelight. Each character has a respective side plot as they deal with being questioned by the police and their lawyers as well as meeting their parents' expectations. It becomes apparent how a persons upbringing can influence their reactions to various situations and this is explored in a lot of detail.

Don't get me wrong there is plenty of investigating and betrayal that keep this plot CRAZY, despite the other themes playing a key role. The gossip app continues to provide clues as to what really went down that fateful day; I began to question my sanity after being paranoid about all the characters by the end. Which was hard because I fell in love with one of them within a few chapters.

Talking of romance, there are vast opportunities for emotional breakdowns due to the heartbreaking scenes that revolved around love interests. Seriously believe me when I say, you will become so invested in everyone's relationships, it is as if we have known these characters for several books. 

One Of Us Is Lying is definitely a debut to look out for, I haven't stayed so attentive in a book for a while.

Pre-order it here with free delivery! 
buy the book from The Book Depository, free delivery


  1. This sounds like such a good read, your review has sold it to me! Haha. The Breakfast Club is also one of my favourite films, so I am even more inclined to pick myself up a copy after hearing that it is loosely based off that too! x

    1. Mine too so I feel as though this book was sent from the heavens! I'm so glad you're interested as I would highly recommend it!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

YALC Survival Guide

I am somewhat of a self-titled YALC veteran. I have attended the event since it began, meaning I have picked up some valuable tips over the years on how to get the most out of the weekend. If you are unaware what YALC is, it is the Young Adult Literature Convention happening in London in the last weekend of July. For 3 days, Young Adult readers get together with over 100 authors to celebrate reading, with panels and signings throughout. It is needless to say that a lot of fangirling goes down. 

If you wish to know what the event is like, here is a link to my vlogs from last year...or a write up of my whole weekend. 

Before the event...
1. Plan aheadI am definitely a planning person and I cannot function at YALC without having a concise plan of what I need to do each day. Every signing, panel and actor photo shoot and free time is scheduled in, one year I even made a spreadsheet. That is how hardcore I am.

If you are travelling to the event, make sure to look up weekend train schedules as …

Back to School Readathon

Hello everybody, exciting announcement today...I'm hosting a Back To School Readathon starting on the 28th August and ending on the 3rd September! 
It will be a very casual readathon, with no rules about specific books that need to be read. Sometimes I find that readathons are too restrictive so I have decided to create one where you can read ANYTHING. Since the theme is 'Back to School' there is an optional rule to read a book set in school and I'm seriously ecstatic about picking one from my tbr (to be read)! 
Mostly this is a ploy for me to diminish the size of my ever growing tbr and with a new school term starting imminently for most students, it's the perfect chance to get as much reading done as possible. The reasoning behind making this one week prior to the end of August is also strongly associated with my never ending dream of receiving my Hogwarts letter and so in my eyes the 1st of September marks the start of a new school year. 
I would love for …